8.22.2010

HEA for Boobward? (Spoiler Warning!)

So, for those who have read and reviewed chapter 34 and found the ending (sans epilogue) not "HEA enough" I have a question - Does this Edward deserve a complete and unimpaired HEA? Let's look back on what he's done - violently attacked and kidnapped Bella, killed a store clerk and a nurse with a family, nearly attacked a child for touching Bella, attacked his own brother, almost killed Newton and a variety of other transgressions. After all of that, should he have complete absolution? Or should he have a reminder that some choices come with a high cost?

What do you think, and why? I'm dying to know, so leave a comment! :)